15. Rashawn Brazell
The 19-year-old Rashawn Brazell was noticed to be missing from his home in Bushwick, Brooklyn on 14th February 2005, and his whereabouts were unknown. Only four days later, his severed body parts were found at the Nostrand Avenue train station!
The forensic team identified his body by matching his fingerprints. Even more tragically, other remains of his body – an arm and a leg – was found in a recycling plant located in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. Frustratingly enough, no arrests have ever been made.